Which Sentence Contains a Restrictive Clause?

A) They decided to meet where the band was performing.
B) The children, sweaty and miserable, piled into the bus.
C) They put the baby, who was fast asleep, in his crib.
D) The girls, overwhelmed by the sale, bought many shoes.
E) The child, who was now wailing, ran toward his mother.

The following sentence (C) contains a restrictive clause: “They put the baby, who was fast asleep, in his crib.”

Explanation:

In sentence C, the clause “who was fast asleep” is restrictive because it specifies which baby was placed in the crib. Without this clause, the sentence would simply state, “They put the baby in his crib,” leaving out the critical detail about the baby’s condition. This additional information is necessary to fully identify the subject of the sentence.

Why the Other Sentences Are Incorrect:

A) “They decided to meet where the band was performing.”
The phrase “where the band was performing” is not restrictive. While it provides additional information about the meeting location, removing it does not change the core idea that they decided to meet somewhere.

B) “The children, sweaty and miserable, piled into the bus.”
The phrase “sweaty and miserable” is descriptive rather than restrictive. Removing it does not affect the main action of the sentence—children piling into the bus. It merely describes their condition.

D) “The girls, overwhelmed by the sale, bought many shoes.”
The phrase “overwhelmed by the sale” is not restrictive. It explains why the girls bought many shoes but does not affect the essential meaning of the sentence—the fact that they bought the shoes.

E) “The child, who was now wailing, ran toward his mother.”
The clause “who was now wailing” is descriptive, not restrictive. Its removal does not change the main idea of the sentence, which is that the child ran toward his mother; it only adds detail about the child’s emotional state.

For instance:

• “The book that I borrowed from the library is fascinating.”
  • In this example, the phrase “that I borrowed from the library” is a restrictive clause. It tells us exactly which book is fascinating. Without this clause, it would be unclear which book is being referred to.

1. What Is a Clause?

Before understanding restrictive clauses, let’s briefly define what a clause is:

• A clause is a group of words containing a subject and a verb.
• There are two types of clauses:
  • Independent Clauses: Can stand alone as complete sentences. For example, “She enjoys reading.”
  • Dependent Clauses: Cannot stand alone and need to be connected to an independent clause. For example, “who enjoys reading.”

2. What Are Restrictive Clauses?

A restrictive clause (also called a defining or essential clause) is a type of dependent clause that:

• Provides critical information about the noun it describes.
• Cannot be removed without altering the core meaning of the sentence.
• Does not use commas to separate it from the rest of the sentence.

Example:

• “The car that he bought last year has broken down.”
  • Here, “that he bought last year” is a restrictive clause because it specifies which car we are talking about. Without this clause, if we just say, “The car has broken down,” it’s unclear which car we mean.

3. How to Identify a Restrictive Clause

Identifying restrictive clauses can be straightforward if you know what to look for. Follow these steps:

Step 1: Locate the Clause

Look for phrases that begin with relative pronouns such as:

• “that”
• “who”
• “whom”
• “which” (though in modern English, “which” is often reserved for non-restrictive clauses)

Step 2: Evaluate the Importance

Ask yourself:

• Is this information essential to understand which person or thing I am talking about?
• If yes, then it’s likely a restrictive clause.
• If no (meaning the information could be removed without altering the fundamental meaning), then it might be a non-restrictive clause.

Step 3: Check for Commas

• No commas: If the clause is essential (restrictive), it should not be set off by commas.
• With commas: If the clause is non-essential (non-restrictive), it will usually be set off by commas.

Example:

• “The students who study hard pass the exam.”
  • Restrictive Clause: “who study hard”
  • Explanation: This clause is essential because it specifies which students we are talking about — those who study hard. Without it, the meaning would be incomplete, as it would just imply that all students pass, which isn’t accurate.

4. Difference Between Restrictive and Non-Restrictive Clauses

It is important to distinguish between restrictive and non-restrictive clauses because they serve different purposes:

Restrictive Clause (Defining Clause)

• Purpose: Provides information that is necessary to understand the noun it modifies.
• No Commas: Restrictive clauses do not use commas.
• Example: “The book that you lent me was very interesting.”
  • The phrase “that you lent me” is essential. It tells us which book was interesting — the one you lent me.

Non-Restrictive Clause (Non-Defining Clause)

• Purpose: Adds extra, non-essential information about the noun.
• Uses Commas: Non-restrictive clauses are set off by commas.
• Example: “My brother, who lives in New York, is coming to visit.”
  • The clause “who lives in New York” adds extra information, but it’s not necessary to understand which brother is coming to visit. We can remove it, and the core meaning stays the same: “My brother is coming to visit.”

5. Common Relative Pronouns Used in Restrictive Clauses

The type of relative pronoun can help you identify restrictive clauses. Here’s a closer look:

• “That”:

  • Used for things, animals, and sometimes people (especially in informal contexts).
  • Example: “The book that you gave me is missing.”
    • Explanation: The clause “that you gave me” defines which specific book is missing.

• “Who/Whom”:

  • Used for people.
  • Example: “The person who called you yesterday is my friend.”
    • Explanation: The clause “who called you yesterday” is necessary to specify which person we are talking about.

• “Which”:

  • Sometimes used for things, though in modern English, “that” is often preferred for restrictive clauses.
  • Example: “The tool which he designed is efficient.”
    • Preferred Modern Usage: “The tool that he designed is efficient.”

6. Examples to Illustrate Restrictive Clauses in Action

Here are a few more examples to show how restrictive clauses function:

1. “The cake that Mary baked was delicious.”
   • Restrictive Clause: “that Mary baked”
   • Explanation: It tells us which cake was delicious. Without this clause, the sentence would be vague.
2. “The manager who attended the meeting will give the presentation.”
   • Restrictive Clause: “who attended the meeting”
   • Explanation: This clause specifies which manager will give the presentation.
3. “The movie that we watched last night was thrilling.”
   • Restrictive Clause: “that we watched last night”
   • Explanation: Defines which movie was thrilling. Without it, the sentence would be unclear.

7. Why Is Understanding Restrictive Clauses Important?

Being able to identify and correctly use restrictive clauses enhances clarity in your writing. Here’s why it matters:

• Ensures Clear Communication: When you provide essential information about a noun, you are helping readers understand exactly what or who you are referring to.
• Avoids Ambiguity: Without restrictive clauses, sentences can become vague or misleading. For example:
  • Vague: “The students passed the exam.” (Which students?)
  • Clear: “The students who studied hard passed the exam.”
• Improves Grammar and Syntax: Proper use of restrictive clauses ensures grammatical correctness, especially concerning punctuation rules (no commas).

Conclusion

A restrictive clause is an essential part of a sentence that provides critical information about a noun. It tells readers exactly who or what the speaker is referring to, and it should not be set off by commas. Restrictive clauses often start with relative pronouns like “that,” “who,” or “whom” and are essential for conveying precise meaning. By mastering restrictive clauses, you can write sentences that are more accurate, informative, and easier to understand.

Key Takeaway: If you find a phrase in a sentence that provides vital information about the noun, and it is not set off by commas, it is likely a restrictive clause. Understanding how and when to use restrictive clauses ensures that your writing is clear, concise, and grammatically correct.

Still have questions about restrictive clauses? Whether it’s grammar, writing, or any other academic subject, our professional tutors are here to assist you with your assignments. [Contact Us Now]!

Interactive Quiz: Can You Identify the Restrictive Clause?

Think you’ve mastered restrictive clauses? Test your skills with this quick quiz! For each sentence, identify the restrictive clause and explain why it’s essential.

1. Question

Identify the restrictive clause in this sentence:
“The dog that barked all night belongs to my neighbor.”

• Answer: “that barked all night”
• Explanation: This clause specifies which dog is being referred to. Without it, the sentence would simply state, “The dog belongs to my neighbor,” which lacks clarity about which dog is meant.

2. Question

Which sentence contains a restrictive clause?
A. “The book, which I bought yesterday, is on the table.”
B. “The book that I bought yesterday is on the table.”

• Correct Answer: B
• Explanation: In sentence B, “that I bought yesterday” is a restrictive clause because it specifies which book is being discussed. Sentence A uses a non-restrictive clause (“which I bought yesterday”), as the information is extra and separated by commas.

3. Question

Does this sentence contain a restrictive clause?
“The students who arrived early got the best seats.”

• Answer: Yes
• Restrictive Clause: “who arrived early”
• Explanation: This clause is essential to the meaning of the sentence, as it specifies which students got the best seats.

4. Question

Remove the restrictive clause and see how the sentence changes:
“The car that she drives is new.”

• Without the Clause: “The car is new.”
• Observation: Without the clause “that she drives,” the sentence becomes unclear, as it doesn’t specify which car is new.

5. Challenge Question

Choose the correct use of a restrictive clause:
A. “The teacher who gave us homework is absent today.”
B. “The teacher, who gave us homework, is absent today.”

• Correct Answer: A
• Explanation: The restrictive clause “who gave us homework” in sentence A specifies which teacher is absent. In sentence B, the commas make it non-restrictive, implying extra information about the teacher.

Your Score:

• 5/5: Grammar Pro! You’ve got restrictive clauses mastered.
• 3-4/5: Great work, but a little more practice can help!
• 1-2/5: Don’t worry—review the examples above, and try again!

Bonus Resource

Need more practice? Free worksheet on reflective clause and test your knowledge further!